This is Mazon Monday post #349. What’s your favorite Mazon Creek fossil? Tell us at esconi.info@gmail.com.
In August 2026, Gordon Baird, who unfortunately passed away suddenly on November 3rd (see Gordon C. Baird (1946–2026) RIP), was the lead author of “Mazon Creek-type Lagerstätten in Pennsylvanian Coal Basins of the US Midcontinent: Biotic Associations and Depositional Frameworks,” published in the journal Sedimentologika. The paper is open access and is available on ResearchGate.
Abstract
The Mazon Creek fossil beds of northern Illinois are famous for producing
some of the world’s best-preserved fossils from the Pennsylvanian Period, about 307 million years ago. These fossils are found inside ironstone (siderite) concretions that formed rapidly around plants and animals as they were buried. Because of this unusual style of preservation, even soft-bodied creatures—like jellyfish, worms, and the mysterious “Tully Monster”—survive in remarkable detail. For decades, the Mazon Creek has been known for two distinct fossil communities: the plant-rich Braidwood association from nearshore environments, and the more marine Essex association full of jellyfish, shrimps, and other sea life.This study brings together the largest systematic sampling effort ever conducted at Mazon Creek—over 300 000 concretions collected from more than 350 sites—and compares them with new fossil discoveries from similar rocks across Illinois, Indiana, Missouri, and Oklahoma. We combine detailed descriptions of the preserved fossil assemblages, and show them to represent real, repetitive ecological groupings shaped by ancient environmental gradients.
Our work also demonstrates that Mazon Creek-style fossil deposits are not unique to Illinois: similar environments and fossil communities occurred widely across the ancient U.S. Midcontinent as well as in Europe. These findings help us understand how rapid sea-level rise, coastal flooding, and tidal currents created the conditions that allowed such exceptional fossil preservation, offering a window into ancient ecosystems rarely preserved in the rock record.

This paper pulls together decades of fossil collecting data from Pennsylvanian coal deposits, including Mazon Creek and other localities around the American Midwest. Much of the collecting took place during the 1970s and 1980s, before mine reclamation and vegetation made many of these sites difficult or impossible to access. The authors discuss sites from around Illinois, Indiana, Missouri, Iowa, and Oklahoma. Similar sites in Europe, from England, France, and Poland, are also mentioned.
The big picture question the paper addresses is… Is Mazon Creek unique, or is it one particularly spectacular example of a recurring type of Carboniferous environment and preservation?
Baird et al. build upon the site classifications developed in the earlier paper “283,821 concretions, how do you measure the Mazon Creek? Assessing the paleoenvironmental and taphonomic nature of the Braidwood and Essex assemblages” (see Mazon Monday #281). They apply those classifications to many of the localities described in this paper and its supplemental data. For many sites, the authors provide detailed fossil census data, including the number of concretions sampled, the proportion containing plants or animals, the number of barren concretions, and the abundance of particular fossil groups. These data allow the individual sites to be compared with the familiar Braidwood and Essex associations at Mazon Creek.
The classifications are Braidwood, Will-Essex, and Kankakee-Essex.
- The Braidwood association represents the more landward end of the environmental gradient. These localities tend to contain abundant plant material, terrestrial organisms washed into the water, and relatively low-diversity freshwater to brackish-water animals. Characteristic aquatic fossils include non-marine bivalves, syncarid shrimp, Euproops, fish remains, shark egg cases, and other organisms tolerant of stressed nearshore conditions.
- Will-Essex represents the transitional, more shoreward marine environment. Benthic organisms are important, particularly bivalves and burrowing organisms. Mazonomya is especially characteristic of some localities.
- Kankakee-Essex represents the more distal marine end of the gradient. These sites can contain enormous numbers of cnidarians, especially Essexella. Tullimonstrum is restricted to these Kankakee-Essex localities in their dataset.
The authors regard Pit 11 as an extreme example of the Kankakee-Essex association. At one Pit 11 locality, researchers collected 1,935 concretions. Only about 6% contained plants, while nearly 77% contained animals. They found an extraordinary 1,268 Essexella, representing more than 85% of the animals at the site. There were also unusually large numbers of Etacystis, Octomedusa, and 21 Tullimonstrum.
Baird visited many sites familiar to with us, including Mazon River sites, Pit 11, as mentioned, the Sunspot mine in Fulton County, the sites around Terra Haute, IN, and even the spoil pile southwest of Danville, IL we visit twice a year.
3.9.6 Locality 381
This locality, an abandoned Chicago and Harrisburg mine (no. 24) is on the Danville SW 7.5′ quadrangle, south of Catlin (see supplementary material for complete details). Among 368 concretions, collected on multiple visits between 1979 and 1983, approximately half of the concretions yielded plants, with 6 % animals, and the remainder barren or unidentifiable. Dominant taxa in the plant fraction are the tree fern foliage element Pecopteris with 42 specimens and the needle-like lycopsid foliage element Cyperites (Lepidophylloides) in almost equal numbers at 44 specimens. By contrast, pteridosperm elements are solely represented by five compound neuropterid specimens. Although numbers of animals were generally low, this deep mine sample is notable for its bivalve component, which accounts for about twothirds of the entire animal fraction. Clams include Myalinella, Aviculopecten, and Dunbarella, of which Dunbarella is the most numerous, represented by nine specimens. In many Illinois Basin cyclothemic units Dunbarella is a recurrent “paper pecten”, known to occur in dark grey to black, dysoxic, marine facies, particularly, in the basal condensed portions of Desmoinesian transgressive core shale units (Heckel, 1977, 2008). The pectinid count and dark appearance of the spoil cone at Catlin suggest a northward transition to thinner, distal dysoxic Energy Member facies closer to Danville. This mollusk-rich assemblage appears to be similar to that observed in dark grey shale deposits in peripheral portions of the Energy Member in southern Illinois (Palmer et al., 1985), understood to record some kind of oxygen-stressed marginal marine setting, though Braidwood-type in faunal character.
The paper concludes that Braidwood-type associations in both North America and Europe represent a recurring freshwater-to-nearshore-brackish environmental setting. Their geological model ties everything together. During the Pennsylvanian, large tropical peat mires occupied very low-relief coastal landscapes near the equator. During periods of Gondwanan glacial retreat, global sea level rose. The rising water didn’t simply produce an instantaneous marine flooding surface. Instead, estuaries migrated inland and progressively drowned the coal swamp. Rivers and tidal currents carried enormous quantities of mud and silt into the newly flooded landscape. These sediments accumulated rapidly above the peat.
Ultimately, the Francis Creek Shale represents one of these transgressive clastic wedges deposited above the Colchester Coal. Organisms living in the estuary, along with plants and terrestrial organisms washed in from nearby land, were rapidly buried in the mud. Early siderite formation around decaying organic remains then produced the concretions responsible for the extraordinary preservation.
Mazon Creek may be extraordinary, but the geological processes that created it were not unique.
9 Conclusions
Upper Carboniferous siderite concretion-hosted Lagerstätten appear to be a largely time-specific facies linked to repeated burial of tropical peat units during marine transgressions. The prime example of this type of preservation, the Middle Pennsylvanian (Asturian) Mazon Creek biota from
the Francis Creek Shale Member in northeast Illinois displays two faunal associations, the nearshore Braidwood aquatic and terrestrial flora and fauna and the estuarine marine Essex fauna, further subdivided into the Will-Essex and Kankakee-Essex subassemblages based taxic composition. These biotas are herein described in unpublished census tables showing the ratio of plants to animals, the differential abundance and/or scarcity of different taxa collected, and the proportions of barren and fossil-bearing concretions in samples. We then present unpublished census data from equivalent Essex fauna localities in western Illinois, both Braidwood and Essex localities in western Missouri, and Braidwood fauna occurrences in eastern Oklahoma. New census lists from earlier, Westphalian C (Bolsovian Substage) Braidwood association census localities are described from the Arkoma Basin of eastern Oklahoma, and younger, topmost Westphalian (Cantabrian Substage) Braidwood association samples are described from the Energy Member in Vermilion County, east-central Illinois. A still-higher Braidwood association biota, found in association with upright tree stumps, is described from the basal Busseron Member (topmost Cantabrian substage) in southwestern Indiana. Additional Mazon Creek type localities in the United States, not included in the present study, are briefly described and tabulated.Data from North America indicate that most localities are characterized by the Braidwood association mix of numerous plants, freshwater or nearshore aquatic taxa, and washed-out terrestrial animals. This strongly suggests that the Braidwood association is a recurrent feature of coal roof facies. Moreover, siderite nodule hosted localities in Britain, France, and Poland solely display Braidwood-type biotas. This pattern further confirms that the suite of Braidwood faunas observed in both North America and Europe collectively represents the expression of freshwater to nearshore brackish, low latitude Pennsylvanian nearshore biofacies.
In contrast, the Essex fauna is presently known only from the Francis Creek Member in Illinois and from stratigraphically equivalent shales in western Missouri. The rarity of this faunal assemblage raises the question of whether the Francis Creek Shale and its stratigraphic equivalent in Missouri record a unique bioevent in the Pennsylvanian succession or whether its general absence elsewhere is simply a product of chance. We take the view that it is recurrent, at least in North America. Based on a study of the Energy Shale in southern Illinois, it appears very possible that a future concerted search through Energy Member coal roof mine spoil deposits in this area may turn up concretionhosted Essex fauna taxa similar to those that occur in the Francis Creek Shale.
Additionally, the authors explicitly argue that additional Mazon Creek-type Lagerstätten probably remain undiscovered and suggest that renewed searching, particularly involving regional fossil clubs and amateur collectors, could reveal important new sites.
BTW, ESCONI and Jack Wittry are mentioned in the first paragraph of the introduction.
1 Introduction
The Middle Pennsylvanian Mazon Creek Lagerstätte in northeastern Illinois is notable for yielding the greatest number of soft-bodied fossil organisms to the greatest number of fossil collectors in the world. As such, this is truly a “people’s Lagerstätte”, publicly accessible as a managed fossil collecting area under supervision by the Commonwealth Edison Utility Company (Earth Science Club Of Northern Illinois, 2020). Based on Seilacher’s (1970) original
definition for Fossil-Lagerstätten, the Mazon Creek deposits could be considered a blend of both types: Konservat, known for exceptional fossil quality, and Konzentrat, known for exceptional fossil abundance (e.g., Kimmig & Schiffbauer, 2024). Although the fossil localities (and their corresponding preservation type) are traditionally referred to as “Mazon Creek”, the numerous collection sites are spread across a five-county region bordering the Mazon River, a tributary of the Illinois River, in northeastern Illinois, including Will, Kankakee, Grundy, LaSalle, and Livingston counties. Given that fossils were first collected along the banks of the Mazon River, the name Mazon Creek stuck, even though the vast majority of the specific concretion collecting areas are found in coal mines nearby the towns of Braidwood, Essex, Coal City, Morris, and La Salle. For over two centuries, variably intense collecting has led to hundreds of publications on the flora and fauna collected from these fossil deposits. Plant fossils comprise over 400 floral form species and genera, corresponding to approximately 100 whole plant taxa (Wittry, 2006), representing the highest estimated floral diversity recorded for the Pennsylvanian of North America (Horowitz, 1979). No less than 320 species of animals were described from this deposit as of the late 1970s with an updated total of greater than 500 species across 11 phyla and 23 classes (Wittry, 2012). The Mazon Creek Lagerstätte comprises the long-known Braidwood fossil association (abundant particulate plants, a sparse, nearshore aquatic fauna, and washed-in terrestrial animals) and the more diverse estuarine marine Essex fauna of cnidarians, worms, crustaceans, and problematica (R. G. Johnson & Richardson, 1966).
Especially interesting are the photos of buckets on the roof of the Field Museum. There is no mention of damage to the roof, which may or may not be true. (Wow! Those are good looking concretions on the top of that bucket!)

Leave a Reply