This is Throwback Thursday #344. In these, we look back into the past at ESCONI specifically and Earth Science in general. If you have any contributions, (science, pictures, stories, etc …), please send them to esconi.info@gmail.com. Thanks!
Roy Plotnick presented “Lyell in Chicago: A Historic Collection Illustrates a Missing Chapter in 19th Century Geology for the ESCONI November 2026 General Meeting. The presentation documented Charles Lyell’s visit to the United Status nearly 200 years ago. Lyell did not visit Chicago (it was less than 10 years old at the time!), but his collection of Silurian made their way into the Field Museum’s collection back in the 1960’s.
From June 17–24, 1841, Charles Lyell followed the footsteps of Roderick Murchison by collecting in “Silurian” localities in Wales and the Welsh Borderland of England. This collection travelled with Lyell during his first visit to America that began in July of that year. At some point, it ended up in James Hall’s possession and then eventually at the Field Museum in Chicago. Lyell’s trip to collect these specimens has never been documented and the collection itself has never been described.
Using Lyell’s notebooks, with the assistance of experts, we have reconstructed his collecting journey. As far as possible, again with expert advice, we have identified the specimens in the collection, determined their localities, and placed them within the current stratigraphy for the Ordovician and Silurian. This collection, and the interactions between Charles Lyell and James Hall, were key to the nascent efforts to produce a global correlation for those time periods.

Leave a Reply